USSBurritoTruck

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

I dunno, I've never heard of it.

1

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

Not canon, but

spoiler

Jurati is in The La St Arship comic as the chief engineer on the Starfleet ship whose mission it is to try and keep the Federation together after the burn in the 31st century. She also made the clone of Kirk we saw at the Daystrom Station in PIC season 3

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

Basically, the AR wall is a giant LED screen that they can use to display a background of some sort as opposed to having the actors acting against a green screen. It allows them to create some interesting locations for stories without without having to build a full set or find an appropriate location.

SNW even uses it for their main engineering aboard the Enterprise, though that’s why we didn’t see main engineering at all in season three; it apparently takes too long to set up and break down in front of the AR wall.

The technology is becoming increasingly common, and some of them do use generative AI. However, the one the Star Trek productions use does not.

4

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

I remain skeptical. Unnamed sources claiming it was someone on the art department who hand drew it is not entirely convincing. I'd like to see the layers. Or, failing that, an explanation for why the characters are so inconsistent and indistinguishable from one panel to the next. Why the shadows don't make any sense. Why the hands when we see them don't make sense.

Also, the article claims the AR wall is using machine learning, and I'd like to see a source on that. My understanding, based on what the VFX supervisor for Disco, PIC, SNW, and SFA has said is that their AR walls do not integrate machine learning.

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

The PIC s3 writer's room.

1

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

Not to belabour the issue, but it seems like Tatosky might not be entirely convinced that those panels are not LLM generated.

3

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

I follow Brian Tatosky on mastodon as well, and he says, "as far as I know" it was drawn and coloured by the art department. That is not a confirmation one way or the other.

But I went through and screenshot every image that was on screen of the comic pages. I would believe the art department mocked up the cover, but you cannot convince me the interior pages shown weren't shat out of an LLM.

7

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 3mo ago

I am a lot more annoyed at an official Trek production using AI slop comic book art that I probably should be.

That aside, this episode didn't do much for me. I like SFA when it's about Academy cadets doing school stuff. I really could not care less about Captain Ake's tragic backstory, or Nus Braka.

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

Well, yeah.

I only listed things the Federation was directly involved in, unlike the OP.

9

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

Hey, remember in ‘The Conscience of the King’ when we found out that the governor of a colony massacred half the population because they were experiencing a famine?

Remember ‘The Menagerie’ when we found out you can still get the death penalty in Federation?

Remember how Kirk consigned the populations of two planets, one of which told the Enterprise in no uncertain terms to not visit, to violent war, because he didn’t like the way they were conducting their ongoing conflict in ‘A Taste of Armageddon’?

Remember in ‘A Wolf in the Fold’ where we learned that Starfleet has alliances with less advanced worlds where the population is amenable to being “pleasure planets” for officers on shore leave to engage in sex tourism?

Remember when Kirk used a primitive culture to fight a proxy war with the Klingons in ‘A Private Little War’, and then abandoned them when he got a bit sad?

Remember that a founding member of the Federation, the Tellarites, were willing to keep a planet out of the Federation so they could continue exploiting its rich resources that the locals weren’t able to properly defend on their own, in ‘Journey to Babel’?

Remember ‘Patterns of Force’ where a former Academy instructor and renowned Federation historian introduced Nazism to a pre-warp society, even becoming their Führer?

Remember when we found out in ‘The Cloud Minders’ that an explicitly Federation member world maintains a rigid caste system?

Remember ‘To Short a Season’ where the plot was based around a Federation admiral who had supplied weapons to terrorists as a commander, resulting in a coup where the terrorist leader took control of their planet?

Remember how in ‘The Measure of a Man’, the Federation demanded that a sentient being, a member of Starfleet for 24 years, submit himself to be experimented upon so the Federation could make more of his kind for their own use?

Remember when in ‘The Survivors’’, Picard choose to do nothing to the being who committed complete genocide of a sentient species, claiming there were no laws to fit his crime?

Remember ‘The Offspring’ when an Admiral shows up to take away Data’s child for study, despite the fact that he won his right to live in ‘The Measure of a Man’?

Remember when Worf murdered a candidate for head of a foreign state in ‘Reunion’ and got off with a slap on the wrist?

Remember ‘The Drumhead’ when a respected former Starfleet admiral comes aboard the Enterprise and begins to persecute a crewpoerson based on who his grandfather was, on the basis of the fact that he committed a thoughtcrime, and Worf went along with it?

Remember in ‘Ensign Ro’ how a Starfleet admiral colluded with agents of a fascist states to blame refugees of that fascist’s states occupation of their homeworld for an attack the fascists commited, and to that end ordered a disgraced Starfleet officer to offer weapons to the refugeers?

Remember when Picard ordered the creation of a virus that might have potentially committed genocide against the Borg in ‘I, Borg’?

Remmber in ‘Descent’ how Admiral Nechayev fed picard a bowl of shit for not deploing a virus that might have caused the genocide of the Borg?

Remember ‘The Pegasus’ where we learned that an admiral was trying to recover a lost Starfleet ship that could cloak, in blatant violation of their treaty with another galactic power?

Remember how in ‘Journey’s End’ the Enterprise is tasked with the forced relocation of Federation citizens to appease a fascist state, and then when those citizens refuse to be relocated, the Federation chooses to abandon them?

Remember how Admiral Nechayev ordered the Enterprise to aid a fascist state in rooting out the freedom fighters opposing their occupation of territory that used to belong to the Federation?

Remember ‘Captain Pursuit’ where Sisko is willing to release a sentient being who is being hunted for sport to his hunters?

Remember how often Sisko was opposed to the actions of freedom fighters working against the fascist state occupying their homes, beginning with ‘The Maquis’?

Remember ‘Homefront’ and ‘Paradise Lost’ when the Federation implemented martial law on Earth, including mandatory random blood screening of its citizens?

Remember when terrorist organization tried to implement their conservative ideals on a resort planet, and Worf joined them, and then saw no repercussions for doing so in ‘Let He Who is Without Sin…’?

Remember in ‘For the Uniform’ how Sisko used biological weapons against freedom fighters resisting a fascist occupation of their homes?

Remember how in ‘Inquistion’ we learned about Section 31, an secret organization within Starfleet intelligence that exists to carry out Starfleet’s dirty business?

Remember when Sisko used a former intelligence operative from a fascist state to trick a different fascist state into joining a war effort in, ‘In the Pale Moonlight’?

Remember ‘The Seige of AR-558’ where we see Starfleet officers committing war crimes, and collecting trophies off the bodies of fallen enemies soldiers?

Remember how in ‘When it Rains…’ we learned that Section 31 infected Odo with a biological weapon to kill the Changelings, and in ‘Extreme Measures’ that the Federation Council refused to provide a cure, even after one had been created?

Remember when Worf assissinated a foreign head of state in ‘Tacking Into the Wind’ at Sisko’s implied behest, and faced no consequences for doing so?

Remember how Janeway murdered a being, who had commited no crime and had been explicitly stated as being helpful to the crew, as he begged for his life in ‘Tuvix’?

Remember in ‘Nothing Human’ when we learned that the Voyager database includes the works and psychological profile a fascist scisentist whose research involved committing atrocities on the population of a planet his people had occupied and forced into labour?

Remember when Tom Paris was senstanced to solitary confinement on the bridge by Janeay, an act that is currently considered cruel and unusual punishment, in ‘Thirty Days’?

Remember ‘Equinox’ where we learn a Starfleet crew has been knowingly capturing and murdering sentient lifeforms to fuel their ship?

Remember how in ‘Shadows of P’Jem’ we found out that the Vulcans maintained a long range listening outpost under a site they declared sacred to their culture?

Remember in ‘Cogenitor’ when Archer refused to grant asylum to an alien being who was kept in sexual slavery?

Remember when Archer tortures someone for information in ‘Anomaly’?

Remember in ‘Damage’ when Archer orders the NX-01 crew to board an alien ship and steal vital components of their warp drive, leaving those beings stranded in a hostile and dangerous region of space?

Remember ‘Kir’Shara’ where we saw Shran torture Soval to assess the truth of informaiton he was being given?

Remember in ‘Bound’ how Archer accepted a gift of three slaves?

Remember ‘Star Trek: Insurrection’ where the Federation was allied with a state that keeps slaves, and agreed to force relocate a population so they could gain access to the resources of that people’s planet?

3

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

I later learned she was also supposed to be Cardassisn, which I totally missed as well.

I found that Cardassian prosthetic they used to be pretty distracting. I'm guessing it must have been one of those full face deals based on how Tawny Newsome's features were flattened out and broadened, giving her an almost uncanny valley situation. Pretty sure the Cardassian prosthetic in the 90's shows were more appliques glued in place, and then make-up was applied on top. Also, the fact that Illa wasn't grey like every other Cardassian we've seen really bumped me. It wasn't until the reveal that she's also part Trill that the skin tone, and less obvious ridges stopped being annoying. I still don't think it was a great prosthetic.

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

Jeepers! Thanks for catching that

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

Damn, I've been enjoying the series more than I ever expected to, but this episode really got me.

3

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

868858.7 - that puts it pretty definitively after DSC season 5

Was that in question Reno being an instructor would seem proof enough that it was after her time on Discovery.

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

You’re going to need to back those claims up with some actual evidence beyond whiney youtube conspiracy nonsense

2

USSBurritoTruck @startrek.website 4mo ago

You do understand the differences between modern television making and 25 years ago, correct?

If modern era Trek was really so unsustainable, would they be going into their ninth year of it?